AQUAPONICS- DETAIL.. MEDIA BED TECHNIQUE,NUTRIENT FILM TECHNIQUE & DEEP WATER CULTURE TECHNIQUE

SYSTEM UNIT
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES

 




MEDIA BED TECHNIQUE
Simple and forgiving design
Ideal for beginners
Alternative/recycled parts can be used
Tall fruiting vegetables are supported
All types of plants can be grown
Multiple irrigation techniques
Many types of media can be used
High aeration when using bell siphons
Relatively low electrical energy
Medium captures and mineralizes solids
Very heavy, depending on choice of media
Media can be expensive
Media can be unavailable
Unwieldy at large scale
Higher evaporation than NFT and DWC
Labour-intensive to construct
Flood-and-drain cycles require careful
calculation of water volume
Media can clog at high stocking density
Plant transplanting is more labour-intensive
as the media needs to be moved
If water delivery is not uniform, plant
performance may differ from bed to bed



NUTRIENT FILM TECHNIQUE
 More cost-effective than media beds on
large scale
Ideal for herbs and leafy green vegetables
Minimal water loss by evaporation
Light weight system
Best method for rooftops
Very simple harvesting methods
Pipes spacing can be adjusted to suit
different plants
Well researched by commercial
hydroponic ventures
Smallest water volume required
Minimal labour to plant and harvest
More complex filtration method
Water pump and air pump are mandatory
Cannot directly seed
Low water volume magnifies water quality
issues
Increases variability in water temperature
with stress on fish
Water inlet pipes can easily clog
Vulnerable to power outages
  




DEEP WATER CULTURE TECHNIQUE
More cost-effective method than media
beds on large scale
Large water volume dampens changes in
water quality
Can withstand short interruptions in
electricity
Minimal water loss by evaporation
Well researched by commercial
hydroponic ventures
Polystyrene rafts insulate water from
heat losses/gains keeping constant
temperatures
Shifting rafts can facilitate planting and
harvest
Rafts provide biofilter surface area
DWC canals can be fixed with plastic
liners using almost any kind of wall
(wood, steel frames, metal profiles)
Can be used at multiple stocking densities
More complex filtration method
Very heavy unit
High dissolved oxygen required in the
canal, and a more sophisticated air pump is
required
Plastic liners must be food-grade
Polystyrene sheets are easily broken
Tall plants are more difficult to support
Large water volume increases humidity and
the risk of fungal disease


Previous
Next Post »